In September she gave a monologue while working at the store. During this time she yells at someone who walks in the store. The customer then walks away. She is condescending toward her customers, rude behind their back, and rips them off. Her taste in music changes frequently, as she is constantly making sure that the music she listens to isn’t popular .
Michelle seems to be fond of Cecil. When she calls him to let him know his Woody Guthrie album has arrived, she insults his taste in music, but then asks if he could hang out at the store, because she gets lonely and needs more human contact. She also invited him to her exclusive "90s Fashion Night" party, though she canceled that event when he accidentally read the invitation out on the air.
A year later, while listening to "hopcore" (a genre she invented, consisting of recordings of her hopping on the floor as quietly as possible), she notices Intern Maureen enter the store looking for some new music. After letting Maureen try several different albums available, she decides to give her the hopcore album, admitting though she likes being lonely, it is also nice to have Maureen in the store. Her increasingly detailed descriptions of Maureen's appearance whenever she enters the store imply the beginnings of a crush. Maureen shows Michelle one of the Strangers up close and protects her from being devoured by it. She appears to be growing quite fond of Maureen, calling her "sweet" and "a kind person". Shockingly, she even likes Maureen enough to tolerate the fact that Maureen likes country music. They are later seen holding hands and get embarrassed talking about how stupid love is .
- Episode 37 "The Auction"
- Episode 53 "The September Monologues" (vocal appearance)
- Live show "The Librarian" (vocal appearance)
- Episode 64 "WE MUST GIVE PRAISE"
- Episode 65 "Voicemail" (vocal appearance)
- Episode 69 "Fashion Week"
- Episode 72 "Well of Night"
- Episode 77 "A Stranger"
- Episode 81 "After 3327"
- Episode 85 "The April Monologues" (vocal appearance)
- Episode 88 "Things Fall Apart" (vocal appearance)
- Episode 89 "Who's a Good Boy? Part 1"
- Episode 90 "Who's a Good Boy? Part 2"
- Episode 100 "Toast" (vocal appearance)
- Live show "Ghost Stories" (vocal appearance)
- Episode 115 "Council Member Flynn, Part 2"
- Episode 119 "eGemony, Part 3: "Love, Among Other Things, Is All You Need""
- Episode 121 "A Story of Love and Horror, Part 1: “Barks”"
- Episode 130 "A Story About Us"
- Live show "All Hail" (vocal appearance)
- Episode 141 "Save Dark Owl Records" (vocal appearance)
- Episode 160 "The Weather"
- Live show "A Spy in the Desert" (vocal appearance)
- Episode 186 "The Many Lives of Frank Chen"